What’s your opinion on the All-American Potluck? Love them? Loathe them?
I’ve participated in many potlucks over the course of my life and while growing up on Long Island, our family enjoyed many with family and friends. To my parents and aunts and uncles, they were simply a fun and efficient way to bring folks together whether we were at home or at a beach club overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. We always had a ton of fun.
That said, I recently listened to Ina Garten’s podcast, Happy Hour with Ina Garten. I worked for Ina at her flagship store the Barefoot Contessa in Westhampton Beach in the 1980s and of course I have all her books including her latest, Simply Ina. I know her style well.
That said, her podcast with Alison Roman led me to shout to myself, “Alison and Ina: Don’t Dis the Potluck!”
The podcast starts with the usual random chitchat and then leads in to how Alison, who is publishing her next book and opening a shop likes to entertain. The tone is that things are kept simple, accessible and meant to bring folks together. The podcast then rambles along to other topics and, in the end, wraps up with questions from listeners. One listener, Hallie from Massachusetts, asks, ”What are the secrets to organizing a successful potluck?”
A reasonable enough query.
However, Ina and Alison immediately launch into NO.
Striking a somewhat snarky note, they basically state, Just Don’t do it. They hate potlucks. They are difficult to organize. Managing spreadsheets to track who is bringing what is not fun. You run the risk of getting too many bean dishes or dishes with too much garlic etc. Ina offers an alternative spread that involves cooking a ham, and Alison mentions something about control. (But wait aren’t we supposed to be chill, casual and easygoing here?)
All things considered, the listener, in my opinion was left holding the bag with no real potluck tips. I’d say in this economy, exploring the logistics of hosting a potluck is a real need. As many younger families struggle with rising food costs, high interest rates, sky-high insurance costs, the benefits of the communal potlucks are real. The work and the cost of having people over are spread across households and everyone can still come together to share ideas, time, and fun. We all know that dining out is becoming prohibitively expensive on many levels, so why not devise a solution and a remedy for seeing friends and family? When planning the gig maybe ask people to bring an old Faithful, a tried and true family favorite? A dish that’s been in rotation for decades.
Some of my favorite potluck memories involved Mrs. Eschmann’s coffee cake recipe, published in Gourmet Magazine when I was editing the Sugar and Spice column in the 1990s. Another favorite? Aunt Camilla’s Cheeseball, a family favorite with roots in Brooklyn in the 1930s. Another, the iconic Chicken Marbella from the acclaimed Silver Palate Cookbook. A warm and sturdy winter favorite was Mrs. Kenny’s Crockpot Bean Dish that was carted to our house hot and in the actual avocado green Crockpot! Or Mrs. Tomlin’s Chocolate Chip Coffee Cake. Grandma Holmquist’s Hazelnut Cookies, a super simple recipe handed to me decades ago. All these recipes are written down and held in my treasured recipe collection, ready to launch for the next party where everyone can save some dough and bring a dish!
In the end Ina and Alison, tell Hallie to ask someone else.
So, my answer to Hallie is, Just Do it. Ask your friends over. Enjoy their company, have a few laughs, and in the end if it wasn’t perfect, it doesn’t matter. You still got together, saved some greenbacks, and you are ALL having fun and learning together along the way!
And, Alison and Ina? Thanks for the inspiration as always!













So, here is the basic and easily adaptable method for making a quick pho at home:


